I joined Book Riot and Hey YA in September of 2020. Founding co-host Eric Smith left big, hot dog-shaped shoes to fill, but I’ve been having a blast chatting with other founding co-host Kelly Jensen about things we talked to each other about all the time anyway. Kelly and I are both committed to reading diversely, which is not a chore but a joy, and it happens naturally because we’re both interested in a number of different things. BUT there are definitely books that come up multiple times. In total, more than 1387 unique titles have been mentioned on the podcast, and the reason I give such a precise number and then say “more than” is because I didn’t record books that were published as middle grade, children’s, or adult, even though there are tons of excellent crossover books we recommend regularly! Always check the show notes. Here are the top three (sort of — you’ll see) most-mentioned books, and the runners up, since the podcast debuted in September 2017. These numbers are inclusive through episode 89. See after the list for some context and notes as to how I got these numbers. Please note that I counted this by hand, literally going through each set of show notes, so it’s possible for there to be errors. I counted series books as one title, and I took out any books that were not published as YA, which means adult crossover and middle grade crossover did not factor in. Also, because of how linear time works, books published prior to 2020 naturally had more chances to appear than books that have only been out for a year or so, so many of the titles you’ll see here are backlist. Speaking of linear time, if you’re a longtime listener, you may be surprised at some absences and be like, “nah gurl, you have definitely referenced X a lot.” But no. You’re probably feeling that way because there are definitely some author faves ’round these parts. If I had been counting repeat authors, this list might be very different. But I didn’t, and please don’t ask me to, because just getting these numbers took — and I am not kidding or exaggerating because I timed it — more than 8 hours. Jury’s out on whether it was worth the time, but once I started, it felt like it would be more meaningless if I stopped. So, were there any surprises? Tune into Hey YA every other Thursday, anywhere you get your podcasts, and on alternating Thursdays catch Hey YA: Extra Credit for bonus content!
